Monday, 19 March 2012

Dagestan Massacre, 1999: to be blunt...

Morbid curiosty is a terrible thing.

A couple of months ago, I did something terrible to myself.

First of all, I'm not going to recount a history or theology lesson, that's one of the internet's many purposes; in this case, enlightenment.
I'll cut to the chase, (no pun intended...). 'Gore' videos, 'shock' sites, warning disclaimers, content concerns... How graphic could these things be? Surely, with all of the horror films I have in my mental arsenal, and having always been keen to discover the 'real' world beyond the press, (most recently al-Assad's regime), nothing would ever faze me in this way?
The guy with the jar up his arse - comical.
The guy with the horse... Again, I laughed.
So, somehow, I decided to approach the sites differently. I saw some blood in the side bar, so I clicked it.
Nikki Catsouras, aka Porsche Girl... Brutal, but as a teenager, I was always searching for pictures.
Let's try some videos, I decided.
I jumped right into the deep end, having done some hindsight research. I began with the 'Dnepropetrovsk Maniacs' obliterating helpless Sergei Yatzenko. Extremely unnerving, and having realised he survived much of the duration of the filming, it was made all the more upsetting. I did the research, passed the judgements on the murderers, and have copious amounts of sympathy for him and his widow, and within an hour or so, I shook it off. Fine, I thought, rather than stop here, I'll hunt for some more.

This was the biggest mistake of my Internet life.

'Beheading of 6 Russian Conscripts by Chechens', 'Chechens beheading', 'Dagestan beheading', 'Dagestan Massacre 1999'... In the event somebody even reads this, (not that I particularly care, since this blog is intended as merely a venting space), do not watch this video... It's a curse, not just a video. This will stick with you forever. Now, as I said, do all the research into Chechnya, Chechen warfare, Russia, Islam etc as you wish. I'm just stating facts. I cannot stress how bizarre my reaction was, has been, and still is to this video. I cannot stress the multitude of ways in which this has disturbed me and warped me into somebody I wasn't by any means before. These young boys, essentially, preyed upon by older men in a tirade of religious and political distortion, die in this video. They're not shot, they are no detonations, there's nothing quick. One man, granted, flees and is shot off camera eventually. He was, sickly, fortunate. As for the other five? Picture me this: one by one, you and four of your Russian comrades are face down in the dirt. You are unarmed. Within minutes, you'll be murdered. No, you won't be 'beheaded', as the title implies, at least not fully. Your throat will be slit, slowly. You will scream. Your screams will become hisses and gurgling as your vocal chords are severed. You will gasp for air as your oesophagus is torn. But they'll stop at your spinal column. You might flop around, like a fish from water, for a few seconds, (or minutes, in the case of the first conscript slaughtered). Your Chechen captors will laugh at you all the way.

I cannot deal with the thought of being home alone anymore, since watching this video. The screams of those men resound in my head. Every corner or empty room has a Chechen lurking inside it. Every noise is a footstep. At night, even with people present, I cannot leave a room and switch off a light. I am reluctant to turn off my bedside light, or keep my arm outside my sheets for too long.

Here are four reasons why I feel this way, and four reasons not to watch this video:

Number one: In the full version of this video, (which I foolishly made my business to find), after around three minutes in, the first image and audio are of a conscript, face down, bleeding, extensively, gasping through a severed windpipe. A Chechen does move in to further the effort, but this does not kill him. He whines as he is hacked further, but only has the energy and means to continue with those huffing sounds afterwards. This progresses for a couple or so minutes following the final blow. Two minutes may not seem like a long time, but to suffocate through your throat, no doubt ingesting your own blood, this is beyond too long, this shouldn't occur.

Number two: The second 'beheading' demonstrates why the term itself is very misleading. There isn't much to display of this man's brutalisation. What you do see, however, is one of the main aspects of this video which haunts me. I'm not exaggerating, it literally haunts me. I imagine him, reaching to his own head, after his throat has been dismembered, where the opening is almost the entire length of his neck. At first, I thought the head and arm movements was a Chechen re-adjusting him for the camera. On second viewing, (yes, I was outrageously stupid enough to view this more than once), I realised that this almost slow, mechanical movement is indeed the conscript vaguely moving his own head and hand. It's as though he wished to check to see if he was dreaming; perhaps he expected to wake from a nightmare, in bed, any bed, safe, alive, unharmed. Each time I recall it, I want to clasp that hand. However, at night, I often expect that hand to reach up, at the foot of my bed. Or, to leave my bed for the toilet at night, and see him lying beside me, eyes wide open, neck wide open, head turning to look toward me, hand idly drifting.

Number three: This was not so much a physically graphic aspect. Rather, the morning after I had watched this, I wept at this impact. There is a transcription of this man's ordeal. The Chechens toy with him for a minute or so before they decide to kill him. Even without this translation, or knowledge of the Russian language, you unanimously understand the desperation and fear of this young man - this human. This particular scene reinforces that these are humans, being set upon by humans. He begs, he screams, he cries, and he calls out for his mother. I wanted to snatch him from the screen, destroy my laptop so as the Chechens couldn't follow, and hug him. But this was around 13 years ago. He is dead. They're all dead. He never got to see his mother again. None of them did.

Finally, number four: The Chechen rebels... These particular specimens are twisted. They document this. They laugh at the expense of the conscripts throughout. They praise God throughout. This adds to and enhances the grimness of these 16 minutes.

As putrid as this may be, learning that Spetsnaz operatives apprehended the culprits of this video, consisting of capturing and/or killings, was good for me.

But still, this was something of a life changing experience.

I don't hate humanity, as much as it is flawed.

This, however, has consumed me. Granted, my recollections of it are not as profound as initially. Nevertheless, it will never leave me.

As promised; no history, no debate, no theology, no politics. My regards to these are nobody's concern but my own.

I just felt the need to vent. It's been a month, possibly more, and this video still saddens me to the core. I see my brothers, I see my friends, I see my Dad, I see my boyfriend, in those men, particularly in the males I know of the same age as those murdered. Simultaneously, I see the Chechens, I see what they're doing, and humanity's dark potential bothers me. It bothers me very much.

Morbid curiosity is a terrible thing. But then again, so is reality.

I wish I could restore my mind to a point prior to watching this. I genuinely do.

I wish those boys would get out of my head.

I feel like the most disgusting voyeur for having seen this video. On the other hand, I feel by not addressing any personal country/culture related opinion, or indeed condemning or condoning either side, that I'm not performing a disservice. It was tragic. Reacting will only tempt more tragedies.

Rest in peace. I can only hope they sleep sweetly now.

If you have a heart, be careful how you use it around this video.
If you don't have a heart, then you'd probably laugh.

Though, from me, the final comment would be don't watch this video.

18 comments:

  1. I have seen this also and agree with you. It was horrible to waatch, the lack of any compassion and empathy. The perverse pleasure they take in murdering, one by one by one, those boys. That, for all the arguing over soldiers, war, blah, blah, blah,is what they are. BOYS. I too, see young people i know, brother, friends who could easily be them. Begging for there life, on a damp, muddy hillside, miles from home, while a group of madmen slit there throats. ONE, BY ONE, BY ONE. Take care and stay lucky.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Dear Tami,

    I too have watched this video on several occasions. It is a good sign that it has affected you so much, as it means that you are still a human being. On these "gore sites" you see so many comments from people that are voyeurs and think it is funny.

    You are not a voyeur, but your curiosity has gotten the better of you. Although I wouldn't describe it as healthy, I think it is very sobering to witness these kinds of things. Seeing the car accident aftermath has definitely changed the way I drive. Seeing a war video like this has changed the way I view war and freedom.

    Being afraid of a Chechen bogeyman in your house is a little over the top, but YES, be aware of this. These things happen in whatever country you live in, just maybe not in this way. Horrible things are done to people all the time...we need to live cautiously. Life is scary.

    Good luck.

    ReplyDelete
  3. hey
    I just saw this video last week when I was checking out other videos in syria. I have to tell you -I agree with all you said--humans doing this to humans--specially innocent boys that did nothing wrong.
    If they were captured and is during war fine-just put a bullet int heir heads like any normal human being..but...

    goes back to the problem in this world RELIGION-specifically the muslim religion and the muslims-im not prejudice but it is what it is.
    You don 't see videos of catholics beheading muslims cause theyre a different religion? or because it says so in the bible do you?? But tell this to a muslim and is like youre talking to a wall. Blinf faith they call it? I call it ignorance and illiterate, uneducated lowest for of life--the worst part is that theyre all over the world and "insist" of spreading this satanic religion-it sickens me

    look at them-they still live in the biblical times, stoning to death-chopping fingers, honour killings etc--we're in 2013?/ these people are brainwashed beyond repair

    if there is any movement against this barbaric islamic religion I will definetly be a part of it--we need these parasites out of the world forever.

    One last thing..to show what a bunch of hypocrites the muslims are--why don't they all just blow themselves up and die? every single one of them..if you recall every time they blow someone up they say they did it for Allah and they die for him--so lets all help the muslims and kill them all so they can go see their beloved Allah?? makes pefec t sense to me and we're all doing a good deed

    ReplyDelete
  4. Thank you for saving me to see that horrible video and thx for tell to the WEB how stupid is the humanity

    just that peace.-

    ReplyDelete
  5. I watch gore videos all the time but this one is brutal not because of the gore aspect but because of who is being killed. I bet that if you watch Mexican cartels or gangsters killing each other like this, you won't feel much but this is totally different.

    The 19 yr old soldiers were all conscripts who due to circumstances beyond their control got stuck with this bastards, the one who cried like a baby and yelled for his mom was extremely unnerving. At the age where one actually starts having fun, these guys had their throats slit by the pigs. :(

    This wasn't a psycho killing for fun or cartels doing their business but purely religious psy-op as a way of terrorizing Russian troops.

    Those who wish to know the gory details of this Russian- Chechnya war, I would suggest this brutal and very humbling read :

    http://www.amazon.com/One-Soldiers-War-Arkady-Babchenko/dp/0802144039

    ReplyDelete
  6. I watched it and listened to the voices and cries and I cried in hopeless sorrow. I'm so sorry even with heroin to numb the pain I can here the narcotics in their voices (the killers that is ) when your high on opiates emotional pain is numbed and these guys can do anything which is what they did to the young men.heroin is degrading humanity as witnessed here. Listen to the voices

    ReplyDelete
  7. I watched part of this video until I began to feel sick. I also made the mistake of watching the full beheading of an American civil engineer who had been captured and put to death by Muslim psychopaths. As mentioned above, these people are medieval. They have not advanced in the last 1000 years and they want the whole world to be theirs. I saw tv program recently which showed secret cameras in Muslim school in Britain. The school tells everyone that they teach tolerance, peace and understanding but in reality they teach intolerance, hate and segregation. They refer to non- believers as 'Kafirs' who are lower than the animals because they choose not to believe in the Quran. One teacher actually told a class of 50 teenage boys to 'avoid the Kafirs, they are unclean and should never be touched. If one falls in front of you do not attempt to pick them up because they are not worthy'. How long will it before the whole world has to suffer hell like those poor souls in Degastan?

    ReplyDelete
  8. I have had this horrible problem with morbid curiousity. I was young when I first stumbled upon a body that had been turned into globs of mush from a horrific car accident.
    I joined DR website and I wish I never ever was curious to see the various ways people die. Have I become desentisized. No way. I have pain, sorrow, heartache, anger, disgust. If I witnessed a car accident, I will go and see if I can help, hold a hand as a comfort to a trapped and injured or dying victim as help arrives. I will never be one of those people that just walks away, unconcerned.

    ReplyDelete
  9. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Thank you for sharing your thoughts. I had the misfortune of stumbling across a gore video embedded in a silly flash game as well as others uploaded randomly in places where they would normally not be. There are things in this world that are just plain evil and should never be looked upon with anything other than eyes of disgust.

    I heard about this video, and was looking for someone who could shed light upon what was in it. I wanted to know the context, and you provided that for me without me having to watch the video directly.

    You are a human being, and it is only right for you to feel this way.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Evil has always been here on this fallen earth. Too much negative and not enough positive in my life. A time for war and a time for peace. Don't let this video cause you to hate.

    ReplyDelete
  12. I saw the Dagestan video long time ago and it had big impact on me as well. The worst fact is, that the young guys were just conscripts. Which is terrible, because russian draft is pretty brutal. They just raid universities, round up guys and send them to these horrible places with just basic training. But the first video i saw, that had a big impact on me was a guy ripped apart by two jeeps. His hands are tied, one to each jeep and the jeeps just drive away from each other. The video i saw stopped right after one of his arms give way, it's yanked out of it's socked and ripped clean off. This one haunted me a lot, because it was the first one. I wasn't able to get it out of my head until one day, when i finally found the longer version of the video, where you see, that the guy was actually shot approx. half a minute later. Then there was the Vlad-style impalement video, also pretty bad. But the Dnepropetrovsk maniacs video had probably the biggest impact, because it's so much closer to home. Not only in the terms of distance, but also in a social setting. The fact that this happened in post-soviet republic is important to me, because i'm from Czech republic - a former part of a soviet-bloc. Those guys belonged to a middle class. One of them had his own car. Those guys could have been anybody. A young guy who gets whatever he wants from parents, average iq, nothing out of the ordinary about him. Just the absolute emptiness of his mind. No plans, no hobbies, no character, just enormous feeling of entitlement and total lack of empathy. I think that there is SO MUCH of these people around it's downright frightening. Disinterested, aimless, empty-minded people. What's worse, that todays society doesn't exactly view empathy as something necessary or desirable. Empathic people are viewed as weak. I don't know if it's cold-war conditioning, paranoia, mental sickness, or just american media impact, but i really feel like something really bad on a global scale will happen in my lifetime. It feels to me like the signs are everywhere, like there's some kind of societal collapse lurking behind the corner. The fact, that i'm not alone with this view doesn't really help it. I'm not losing sleep over this, but the sense of threat is definitely there. What pisses me off, that the media love to further (maybe even start) these feelings (whether there is something to it or not) via reporting mainly on the bad stuff in the world, and that politicians use this widespread paranoia to hack off one liberty after the other and masses thank them. I'm rambling. I'll stop.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Thank you so much for posting this...I just found out about the video...haven't seen it yet, but I wanted to read about it before actually seeing it. You have saved me a lot of pain and saddest because I now know not to give in to my curiosity.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Just watched it I hope I don't become extremely affected I feel nauseous and feel horrible though

    ReplyDelete
  15. Saw it a few years ago, and it's been in my head ever since. It will always randomly come to mind at the oddest moments...when I'm happy with friends, when I'm alone, on the beach, driving to work, all the time. I always think about the guy who touches his face. The look on his face, actually seeing the life leave his eyes. I'll never forget it. I wish I hadn't seen it but a part of me thinks that by seeing it, in some weird way they weren't all alone up there dying horribly...like we were there too in some small way, that we can share some small part or carry some of the burden. I dunno.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Mates i am muslim too but i got psychological treatment (due to panic attacks and death phobia)after this video thanks to my idiot friend who sent this video to my phone via bluetooth, it affects me so deeply too. It is not about religion in this chechen-russian war both sides have gone mad completely, brainless warmongers :( i cant understand why people dont respect of life instead of killing :(

    ReplyDelete
  17. This is excellent writing, very impressive.

    I disagree with your conclusions though, and your desire to erase the experience of watching such videos from your mind. To do so would erase the knowledge of Man's completely random propensity for cruelty and the bizarre, undulating nature of existence.

    You attach an essential humanity to the victims, imagining them with their families and likening them to your own, and while this is true it doesn't change anything.

    The only conclusion we can hope for is death, and that could come at any time and in any way. The millions of men bayoneted, broken and confused on the battlefields that have scorched this earth since time immemorial are equally as deserving of our empathy and lament.

    But to feel a constant welling of feeling for the tragedies of the world - past and present - would be impossible.

    Life is tragedy.

    That video, and others like it, are just a stark, concentrated reminder of that fact - and in a sense of our own mortality.

    ReplyDelete
  18. I saw this video maybe 12 years ago. It haunts me. Enough that 12 years later I found myself reading about it again. The young man crying out for his mom... it's haunted me ever since. I watched it once... and it was the last time I ever looked at these kinds of videos. It hurts. Everything you said.. I feel. I wish I could not only un-see what I have... but to save them. To go back and stop this from happening. They were all scared and beyond... and it goes far beyond cruelty. Rip men.

    ReplyDelete